Pre-Revolution–1800s
Local historyThe name on the water
Local history traces the Stickles to an early German settler — by one account Hubbard Stickle's forebear — who emigrated and reached the valley a few years before the Revolution. They farmed the highlands among the old families, and their name endured longest on the lake: Stickle Pond was the old name for the water now called Lake Kinnelon, the body of water that would later sit at the heart of the Kinney estate.
A once-published claim that Hubbard Stickle sold this land to Francis Kinney was publicly retracted for lack of any record, and is not asserted here. The family's pre-Revolution German origins come down through local history rather than a surviving deed.
